FORMER U.S. ATTORNEY GENERAL ED MEESE DEFENDS SCOUTING!
(Excerpts from his cover story, "The Fight For Moral Rights," dealing with the attack
on Scouting published in the July issue of Legion, the magazine of the American Legion. Mr.
Meese is Chairman of the Scouting Legal Defense Fund.)
"It is a sad commentary on modern culture that organizations like the Boy Scouts,
with a long record of exceptional service to the young people of our nation, come under
attack when they stand up for traditional values�
The opponents of Scouting have demonstrated that they are unwilling to tolerate the
views and values of others. They often advocate diversity but tolerate only the lock-step
cadence of political correctness. They effectively declare the traditional moral and religious
values held by others to be "socially unacceptable" and seek to impose their ideas of
morality on the rest of society, denying the rights of those who have a different moral
code�
But the constitutional issue involved here is even more fundamental. It isn't just the
rights of the Boy Scouts at issue in this conflict. The same constitutional safeguards that
allow the Scouts to choose their own leaders protect thousands of other groups and
organizations in setting their own standards and membership policies�
Fortunately, many leaders, organizations and citizens have risen to the Scouts'
defense. The American Legion should be commended for their strong statement in this regard�
Throughout the country, courageous leaders and governmental units have followed the Legion's
example�
At no time has Scouting's positive influence been more essential to our nation's future
than it is today. Defending the Scouts against unwarranted attacks, and insuring that they
have continued financial and moral support, will not only preserve an invaluable
character-building organization, but it will help preserve the constitutional rights and
traditional values of all Americans."
Read the entire article here.
FROM THE EDITOR: A Very Busy and Mixed Month For The Scouts!
A great deal has happened in the past month or so--as the unusually long length of
this newsletter attests. Some of the news is good, some not so good.
Certainly the most significant event was the broadcast over most PBS stations
nationwide of the biased and anti-Scout program, "Scout's Honor." We have set up a
special page on our Web site
that catalogues some of the commentary and analysis about this program.
Most of you got an action alert from us asking you to support our efforts to get PBS
to provide equal time for a future pro-Scout program. We appreciate the thousands of you
who responded and contacted PBS! No commitment yet, but we certainly got their attention!
As the saying goes, that is the essential first step in training a mule.
Also of great significance was Senate passage of the Helms Amendment that would cut
off funding to school districts that discriminate against the Scouts. The margin of victory
was only two votes, however, so some of you who live in key states and congressional districts
should watch what happens to this amendment in the final bill. We will let you know.
On a note of less national significance--but something of which we are very proud-both
Ed Meese and I had articles published within the past month in major national magazines.
Mr. Meese's was the cover article, excerpted briefly above, in Legion magazine, the
publication of the 2.8 million-member American Legion. The other is my article,
"The Battle Over The Boy Scouts",
which appeared in the June 11th edition of the influential conservative commentary magazine,
The Weekly Standard.
Finally, thanks to all of you who contributed to the Scouting Legal Defense Fund in
response to Ed Meese's e-mail appeal. If you intended to contribute but have just not
gotten around to it yet, please take a minute to do it now. We need your help! A copy of
his message is posted here or
you can go directly to our secure
online contribution page.
I cannot help but think what a force we could be in defense of Scouting if even a
quarter of the tens of thousands of people who receive this newsletter contributed an average
of only $5 or $10 dollars! The "gay" activists and others attacking Scouting not only
dedicate their time and effort to their cause but huge sums of money as well.
If you are in a position to help by contributing any amount, I hope you will.
Thanks for all you are doing to help defend Scouting!
Sincerely,
Peter Ferrara Editor
P.S. Please help us pass the word by forwarding this newsletter on to others who
are defending Scouting.
WHAT IS HAPPENING TO SCOUTING AROUND THE COUNTRY
(Please note: If the URL is longer than one line, you will have to paste the entire
URL into your browser's address window rather than use the hot link.)
TELEVISION PROGRAM, "SCOUT'S HONOR," CREATES FUROR NATIONWIDE
The broadcast of the biased and anti-Scout program, "Scout's Honor" on most PBS
stations caused sharp reactions from Scouting supporters. For a selection of the
commentaries and analysis please go to a separate page we have set up on our Web site,
www.defendscouting.com .
SOME GOOD NEWS FOR THE SCOUTS�
Helm's Amendment Passes The Senate!
The amendment to the education bill offered by North Carolina Senator Jesse Helms
which would cut off federal funding from school districts which discriminate against the
Scouts passed the Senate by a closer than expected vote of 52-48. The legislation now
goes to a House-Senate conference committee to iron out differences between the two
versions. The House bill includes the Hilliary amendment with nearly identical language.
See article here.
To see how the senators voted, click here.
Rep. Hostettler Introduces Legislation To Stop D.C. Human Rights Ruling.
Indiana Republican Rep. John Hostettler and six other congressmen have introduced
legislation to prohibit the District of Columbia from using any public funds to enforce the
recent ruling against the Scouts by the D.C. Human Rights Commission. The commission fined
the Scouts $50,000 and legal fees on each of two complaints brought by homosexuals who had
been excluded from serving as Scout leaders. See article
here.
Santa Barbara Student Launches Petition To Rescind County Criticism of Scouts
Michael Warnken, a student at the University of California at Santa Barbara, has
launched an initiative petition to gain voter approval of a statement in support of the Boy
Scouts. The initiative would rescind a resolution adopted on March 20 that condemned the
Scouts for excluding homosexual men from serving as scoutmasters and prohibit the county
from discriminating against the Scouts. If 12,500 voters sign the petition, the measure
could appear on the ballot as early as March, 2002. No article available. See the text of
the petition here.
South Florida Scouts and Homosexual Activists Reach Understanding
After a year of discussions, the South Florida Scout Council and the homosexual
activist organization in Dade County have reached an accommodation aimed at reducing local
rancor. The Scouts did not back off the national policy on homosexuals but did agree to
provide additional training to Scout leaders and volunteers to help them deal more sensitively
with homosexual boys. The homosexual activists agreed to support locally the
constitutionally-protected right of association and speech recognized in the Dale Supreme
Court decision. See article
here.
United Ways' Moves To Cut Off Scout Funding Generate Mixed Results
In some places the actions of local United Ways to cut off funding for the Scouts is
backfiring on the homosexual activists who have been pushing for them. In Tucson, where the
City Council effectively forced the local United Way to cut off funding for the Scouts, the
local scout council received about $96,000 in support last year. Following the city's action,
designated donations to the Scouts, which the United Way must pass on, jumped to over $186,000
this year, a net funding increase of $86,000.
In Connecticut, the head of the United Way of Eastern Fairfield County conceded that
the nearly 10% shortfall in expected contributions to their fundraising drive was largely a
reaction to local United Ways in the area cutting off funding for the Scouts.
No articles available.
�BUT SOME BAD NEWS AS WELL.
Presidents of Eight Large Scout Councils Urge Change In Homosexual Policy
At the June annual meeting of the Boy Scouts, the volunteer presidents of eight
large scout councils urged a change in the current policy on homosexuals. The
recommendation from presidents of the Los Angeles, New York, Chicago, Philadelphia,
Boston, Minneapolis, San Francisco and Orange County, California councils was referred
to a committee for further study. See article
here.
Washington D.C. Human Rights Commission Decision Goes Against Scouts
The District of Columbia Commission on Human Rights has ruled that the Scouts
must reinstate as members two admitted homosexuals. The Commission also ordered the
Scouts to pay $50,000 damages to each man and their legal expenses. The Scouts are
planning to appeal. See article
here.
Medical Association Challenges Scout Homosexual Policy
By an overwhelming voice vote at its annual meeting the American Medical Association
(AMA) adopted a resolution calling on "all national youth-oriented organizations to reconsider
any and all exclusionary policies that are based on sexual orientation." While the
resolution did not mention the Scouts specifically, they were the only group identified
during the debate. See article
here.
U.S. Jews divided on support for the Scouts
Jewish congregations in the United States are divided in their response to the
Supreme Court decision upholding the Constitutional right of the Scouts to exclude openly
homosexual men from serving as scoutmasters. Orthodox Jews tend to support the decision
but Reform congregations are mixed in their responses. See article
here.
Oregon District Bans Scout Recruiting, Charges Scouts And Others
The Eugene, Oregon, School Board has banned recruiting by all youth groups during
school hours, instituted a per hour charge for all groups to use school facilities and
withdrawn sponsorship of scout units. The action was taken as a way of withdrawing
support from the Boy Scouts because of their stand on homosexuals. The school board could
not single out the Scouts without violating the anti-discrimination protections of the
Constitution so they withdrew support from all youth groups. See article
here.
MEANWHILE, SOME OF THE NEWS IS JUST WEIRD!
PETA Attacks Scouts Over Fishing Merit Badge
In the category of people-with-too-much-time-on-their-hands-who-also-have-only-a-
tenuous-attachment-to-reality, the radical animal rights group People for the Ethical
Treatment of Animals (PETA) has begun an advertising campaign to force the Scouts to drop
the fishing and fish and wildlife merit badges. PETA claims that these merit badges teach
"young people that hooking, maiming, suffocating, and killing [fish] is acceptable." See
article here.
More Evidence (If More Were Needed!) That Broward County, Florida, Suffers From
Low-wattage Leadership
Broward County, Florida, (yes, THAT Broward County of "hanging chad" fame) recently
provided further evidence that the county's leaders are not the brightest lights in the
string. Slapped with a federal court injunction for its attempted violation of the
Constitutional rights of the Scouts by selectively trying to expel them from the county
schools, the county now has shown that their concerns quickly evaporate when it might cost
money. The local media report that this same protection of sexual orientation ordinance
that led them to try to expel the Scouts is ignored when lucrative contracts or leases with
the federal government might be jeopardized. See article
here.
AND SOME THOUGHTFUL COMMENTARY ON SCOUTING�
"Terrorized By Tolerance" is the text of a full page advertisement recently placed
in the New York Times by the Jewish/Christian coalition group, "Toward Tradition." The
group notes that the word "tolerance" has been so corrupted by the politically correct
crowd that "In 2001, tolerance means you can't say anything is "right" or "wrong" anymore-
except for vaguely defined "intolerance" which is the ultimate evil." Read about it
here.
"American Legion Stands By The Boy Scouts" is a ringing defense of the Scouts by
Joseph Caouette, Chairman of the groups National Americanism Committee. "This assault
on a venerable American institution like the Scouts is an effort to topple yet another
domino in the devaluing of America by those who have a very different vision of what this
nation is or ought to be" he observes. Read commentary
here.
"The Battle Over The Boy Scouts" is the review of the attacks of the past year on
the Scouts by the ACRU's Executive Director and Defend Scouting Newsletter Editor Peter
Ferrara. He concludes in this article published in the influential Weekly Standard that
"a year after the Supreme Court decision it's a standoff." Read commentary
here. |